How to Choose the Right Shingles for Your New Roof (CertainTeed vs. GAF)

Looking to replace your asphalt shingle roof? If so, you may be aware that there's no shortage of modern products to choose from. 

But how do you decide which brand is right for you and your home? Especially when all of these products claim to be the best? Well, that’s what this article is all about. 

In the shingle roofing game there are two main brands that we here at E&E install for our homeowners: CertainTeed and GAF asphalt shingles. 

Both brands offer a quality product that is durable, attractive, and will do a wonderful job protecting your home from water. That being said, one may be better suited to your home, budget, and family. So, to help you make that decision, the information that follows outlines the pros and cons of each.

It’s a quick skim, and by the end, we feel certain you’ll be much more confident going into your roof replacement project.

Let’s break it down.

The Breakdown on CertainTeed Asphalt Shingles

Often seen as the luxury option in the asphalt shingle industry, CertainTeed products are known for their heavyweight design, outstanding durability, and wind resistance. They also offer 16 color options and one of the strongest warranties you’ll find.

Here’s the breakdown on CertainTeed Landmark Pro shingles, CertainTeed’s highest-tier option:

• 16 attractive colors to choose from
• 15-year 110 mph wind-resistance warranty
• 30-year StreakFighter® algae-resistance warranty
• UL 2218 Class 3 impact resistance
• UL Class A fire resistance rating
• Industry leading 50-year limited warranty

Because of their long-term durability and curb appeal, these products may be a great choice if you’re willing to make a slightly higher upfront investment.

GAF Shingles—What You Need to Know

Over recent years, GAF has earned its spot as the most widely installed asphalt shingle brand in the US—and for good reason.

These products are reliable, affordable, and offer a wide range of stylistic choices. Plus, GAF’s Timberline series is one of the most popular roofing lines in the country, offering homes a clean, classic architectural shingle roof look.

Here are a few reasons GAF shingles shine:

• Six color families featuring multiple shades in each
• 40-year warranty terms for all GAF shingles
• 10-year anti-algae warranty on StainGuard labeled products (25 years on StainGuard Plus)
• 15-year wind warranty up to 130 mph winds

All-in, GAF asphalt shingles are a great product at a fair price—making them the go-to for many homeowners nation-wide. 

Which Asphalt Shingle is More Durable: CertainTeed or GAF?

When considering your roofing choices, durability should be top of mind. Why? Because no one wants to replace a roof twice in 20 years.

CertainTeed Landmark Pro shingles tend to be a touch thicker and heavier than GAF products, giving them a slight edge in durability. However, GAF shingles are no slouch—and are also engineered to handle high winds, heavy rain, snow, sleet, and ice.

The bottom line is that both brands will stand strong when installed correctly—and it really comes down to personal preference, and whether you’re willing to invest upfront for CertainTeed’s edge in durability.

How Do Warranties Compare Between CertainTeed and GAF Shingles?

Both CertainTeed and GAF back their products with strong warranties. However, they are structured a bit differently—and depending on your long-term plans, this may affect your ultimate decision.

• CertainTeed offers tiered warranties, with higher-end products coming with longer coverage. CertainTeed warranties are some of the strongest in the roofing industry (backing products with full replacements for 50 years).
• GAF offers a limited lifetime warranty on many of their shingles—meaning their products are covered from manufacturer defects for as long as you live in the home. Additionally, you can qualify for extended warranties when installed by a GAF certified roofer.

How Do CertainTeed and GAF Shingle Costs Compare?

For many homeowners, cost is the determining factor when choosing exterior renovation products. 

Between CertainTeed and GAF asphalt shingles, CertainTeed tends to be a bit pricier for their added durability, modern aesthetic, and leading manufacturer warranties. 

However, shingle costs are only part of the equation. 

Here’s everything your roofing estimate includes: 

• Tear-off and disposal of old shingles
• Underlayment and flashing
• Shingle cost per square foot
• Certified roofing installation labor

So while CertainTeed may cost more per bundle, the total difference on your project may be smaller than you think. 

For a more detailed look at what a roofing replacement will cost for your home, check out E&E’s Free Roofing Estimate Calculator. (We’ll only give you a sales call afterwards if you request one.)

How Do You Choose the Right Shingle Brand for Your Home?

While both CertainTeed and GAF make great roofing products, the choice between the two is ultimately a personal one. 

Here’s what to consider before you make the final call:

• Budget: Which do you value more—cost effectiveness or additional luxury and durability?
• Warranty: How long do you plan to stay in your home? What kind of coverage matters most to you?
• Performance: Is your home exposed to heavy winds, snow, or storms?

At the end of the day, both CertainTeed and GAF shingles are excellent choices for your home. And if you have any additional questions, a certified roofer in your area will be able to make a solid recommendation based on your style, budget, and local climate.

Here’s What Matters More Than Your Choice of Shingle Brand

While choosing a good product is important, roofing installation practices matter even more. And the reason is simple…

The best shingles in the world won’t do their job when poorly installed.

So whether you ultimately decide to go with a new CertainTeed shingle installation or a certified GAF shingle installation, reach out to E&E today.

Because we treat every roof like it’s protecting our own families. And all of your exterior renovations, when installed by our certified crews, come backed by a lifetime workmanship warranty and crews dedicated to overcommunication, quality craftsmanship, and leaving your home respectfully cleaned and cared for.

So don’t wait until you’ve sprung a leak. Reach out today for your complimentary estimate—no strings attached.

Just window shopping? Try our free roofing estimate calculator.